Questions to Consider for Critique

(credit:  Professor Jason Travers)

PRINCIPLES OF ORGANIZATION:

Harmony: Is there relative commonality among the elements?

Variety: Is there diversity among the elements?

Balance: Is it symmetrical/asymmetrical?

Proportion: Relationships in scale (size relative to a constant standard or specific unit of measure)

Dominance: Focal Point/Emphasis

Movement: Is it fast? Slow? Still? Is there a sense of rhythm? Repetition of elements?

Economy: The distillation of the image to the  basic essentials for clarity of presentation; Gestalt: organized whole in experience – everything must be essential

ELEMENTS OF DESIGN:

LINE

Line quality: Is it expressive? Technical?

How do the properties of the line types affect the composition?

Horizontal/vertical: give structure/stability (relate to architecture)

Diagonals: create space

Curve: flowing element (biological reference)

SHAPE

Is it organic or geometric? Is it biomorphic?

What is the figure/ground relationship? Use of positive/negative space? Is there ambiguity?

TEXTURE

Does it have a tactile sensibility? Does it evoke another material?

SPACE

Is it deep? Shallow? Flat? How does it relate to the picture plane?

What is the viewer’s perspective? Eye level? From above? Below?

VALUE

Full range or high contrast? Does it create a sense of light or atmosphere?

COLOR

How would you describe the  palette? (primary, secondary, complementary, split-complementary, monochromatic, analogous, etc)

What temperature is evoked? (warm, cool)

Is the saturation high or low? How does value function with color?

Is there psychological impact based on the palette?

The development of form involves media and techniques and uses the elements of design and the principles of organization to create space and visual unity

FORMAT

Horizontal relates to landscape – vertical to the human form

SUBJECT VS CONTENT

Subject matter is  the literal, visible image  in  a work while content includes the connotative, symbolic and suggestive aspects of the image

EMOTIVE CONTENT

Does the composition have a narrative quality? Does it convey an emotive atmosphere?